Procrastinating via Shortbread

completed shortbread finger cookies on a baking sheet with silpat

My family is getting on a plane this evening, traveling to see two sets of loved ones for Thanksgiving. This means I’m currently putting off packing and thinking about airplane snacks. Therefore, shortbread!

Shortbread is one of my favorite spur of the moment things to bake. It’s simple. It’s forgiving. It’s delicious. I’ve fallen out of the habit recently, but baking shortbread was even a part of my wedding vows.

Here’s how I do it these days: 1-2-3 Shortbread – 1 part sugar, 2 parts fat, 3 parts flour.

  • 6 oz flour – can be pastry or AP or a blend including oat flour. add a bit of rice flour if you like your shortbread crisp.
  • 4 oz cold, unsalted butter
  • 2 oz sugar
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • flavoring and additions such as today’s:
    • 1/2 t vanilla
    • 1/4 c baker’s cut candied ginger
    • 2 T chocolate coated cocoa nibs

Blend flour, sugar, and salt in the bowl of a stand mixer*, fitted with the paddle attachment. Cut the butter into slices or cubes and add to the flour mixture. Mix on low until the dough begins to come together. This will take a long time, ~10 minutes**. You’ll see it progress from floury to sandy to pea sized clumps.

From this: sandy mix of flour and butter being mixed in a green kitchenaid mixer

To thisdough forming pea-sized clumps being mixed in green kitchenaid mixer

Once the dough begins to come together, add your flavorings and mix until well-incorporated.

Once the dough is blended, press it into a log (~2in diameter), or a rectangle or circle (~1/2 in thick), or shortbread molds if you have them and are feeling fancy, and chill for a bit in the refrigerator (30 minutes to… forever, more or less) either covered or wrapped in plastic wrap. Slice or cut into your desired shape and bake at 350ºF until done, just beginning to color at the edges, golden but not deep brown.

(Baking depends on the shape and thickness of your cookies. The fingers I just made took ~17 minutes.)


 

*yes, you really do want a stand mixer for this.

**this is why I said you’d really want a stand mixer

Chocolate Chip Cookies & Why I <3 Twitter

I love the Internet. Sure it’s distracting, bubble-prone, priority mangling, full of vitriol, etc., but it also facilitates conversations in ways that make my life richer, better informed, more connected, and more fun.

Yesterday, I was reading food articles on the bus, like ya do, and came across Food52’s article on Ovenly’s chocolate chip cookies – chocolate chip cookies that just happen to be vegan. I sent a link to my twitter account with one word “Skeptical”. Almost immediately, a couple friends replied that they were going to try it (for science!). Because sometimes peer pressure is great, I decided to try it too. (I even almost followed the recipe! I added 1 tsp of vanilla though. Couldn’t help myself. Oh, and I scooped them smaller so the recipe yield was 25 rather than 18.)

Results:

Friend the First concluded that while these are definitely chocolate chip cookies, they are not chewy enough for her (probably due to the lack of egg). (I haven’t yet heard from Friend the Second.)

I baked the first dozen of my 25. They are… OK. I miss the depth of flavor they’d get from butter and I don’t love how crumbly the dough is (probably due to lack of egg). They also didn’t spread as much as I’d like, so for future batches I think I’ll squash them a bit before baking. I’d definitely make these for office parties, so vegan compatriots could have a tasty dessert that just happened to be vegan. For myself, though, I’ll stick with Toll House, letting the batter rest overnight whenever I manage to plan that far ahead.